Newmarket · insurance brokers
Web design for
insurance brokers in Newmarket.
43 insurance brokerages in Newmarket are listed on Google Maps. We requested all 40 of their websites directly: 1 did not load at all and 9 loaded but looked their age.
We did not sample: all 43 listings in Newmarket were checked, and the 1 broken sites and 0 insecure ones are counted individually, not projected.
What they are built on
5 platforms,
no clear winner.
Of the 40 insurance brokerages in Newmarket with a website, 12 are on WordPress (30%) and the rest are spread across 4 other platforms. 8 still carry a copyright line from 2010 or earlier, which tells you when someone last touched the page.
What actually breaks
Page title does not name the city they work in
on 19 of them.
Out of 40 sites in Newmarket, 19 have page title does not name the city they work in and 12 have no structured data for google to read. We counted each fault separately, so a site with three of them appears in three rows below.
None of the 11 faults we counted in Newmarket requires a rebuild on its own. They add up to one, though, when a site carries four or five of them at once.
Who you are up against
162 reviews
from the top five.
Reviews in Newmarket cluster low and stretch high: the quiet quarter is under 2, the busy quarter is over 46, and one insurance broker sits at 434. 22 listings have fewer than ten, which usually means new or inactive.
Newmarket holds 43 of the 1,013 insurance brokerages we found across the GTA, which ranks it 11th among the 26 places we surveyed. Review counts are not comparable between trades, so none of this means anything outside insurance brokers.
What this means for you
The Newmarket leaders
already fixed this.
4 of the five most-reviewed insurance brokers in Newmarket run a secure site that works on a phone. Between them they hold 1,339 reviews. That is the standard a customer compares you against before reading a word about you.
For a insurance broker the build runs $590 to $3,900 and the month after runs $129 to $990. There is no contract and no charge until you have seen what was built. Full pricing.
Related.
Insurance brokers across the GTA All trades in Newmarket The full GTA report
Insurance brokers elsewhere in the GTA: Mississauga Brampton Markham Scarborough North York Etobicoke
Other trades in Newmarket: Dentists Law firms Accountants Electricians Medical practices Real estate agents
Questions
What people ask us.
How many insurance brokers are there in Newmarket?
43, as of our August 2026 survey of Google Maps listings. That splits into 40 with a website and 3 without one that we could open. Newmarket ranks 11th among the 26 GTA places we surveyed for this trade.
How many Google reviews do I need to compete in Newmarket?
The median among insurance brokers in Newmarket is 8, the upper quarter is past 46, and the five most-reviewed hold 434, 278, 256, 201, 170. That puts fifth place 162 reviews above the median. Reviews are not comparable between trades — this number means nothing outside insurance brokers.
What does a website for a insurance broker in Newmarket cost?
We quote against the size of the business, not the hours. Of the 43 insurance brokerages in Newmarket, most are single-location and land at $590 to $1,190 for the build with $129 to $299 a month after it. You see the finished site before anything is due.
Two minutes
Where does your
own site land?
Everything above came from opening real websites. Yours takes ten seconds: we load it the way a customer would and say what we find, including when the honest answer is that nothing needs doing.
Worth a
conversation?
No pitch deck and no discovery call. Tell us the trade and the city, and we will say what we would do and what it costs.